abujug blogspot

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 6 October 2009

Forward Progress

Posted on 05:24 by hony
Last night during MNF, I was disappointed to watch Adrian "Fumble and/or TD" Peterson have the ball stripped out of his hands by the Packers, who then ran it down the field for a touchdown. Although this was a bold move by the Packers, and understandably plausible given Peterson's propensity to lose the ball at critical moments, I have to admit I was confused because at the time the ball was stripped, four Packers were swarming over Peterson, driving him backwards from his point of forward progress.
This is a tricky issue, and one that the NFL is unclear on. The NFL rulebook cites a player as "down" when:
The runner's forward progress toward the opponents' goal line is stopped by contact with an opponent, with little chance to be resumed. The exact moment at which the player's forward progress stops is subject to the judgment of the officials.
Shouldn't the officials have seen that Peterson's chance of resuming forward progress was essentially nil, given the 900 lbs of Packer defense climbing on his back?
Often, during games, a runner will charge up to a point, and get stopped upright. Defensive players and offensive players slam into this scrum, attempting to push it forward or back. As soon as it is apparent that the player is not moving forwards, the officials blow their whistles like crazy and rush in to stop any shoving or fighting that seems to ensue from these moments.
But Peterson, being clearly pushed backwards by several Packers, heard no whistle, and got no reprieve.
I am not suggesting that Peterson did not fumble. The ball was clearly stripped out of his hands while he was standing upright, moving his feet. But the NFL rule book is too ambiguous on this.
Back on Sept. 13th, Kevin Smith ran up the middle for the Detroit Lions, was stood up and stopped advancing. A player for the New Orleans Saints ripped the ball loose of Smith's hands before the whistle was blown, and ran down the field with it. But the officials reviewed the play and ruled that because Smith's forward progress had stopped, the play was dead. Wasn't that exactly the opposite call than was made with Peterson? And in this case it cost the Vikings 7.

The NFL needs to clearly define this rule and explain it to their officials.


_
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Self Defense at its finest.
    Why I own a handgun. Props to the student who used "cognizant" in a sentence. _
  • Copenhagen Hypocrisy Watch, NASA edition
    I don't really want to jump on the "look, they are getting nothing accomplished" bandwagon because they are getting something ...
  • Swine Flu isn't even as deadly as the normal flu
    The CDC reports that in a normal year, approximately 36,000 Americans die from complications due to the flu. 200,000 Americans are hospital...
  • Pandering to my readers.
    As requested. _
  • "Leaving the Right"
    I wish I had time to write about Sullivan's manifesto he published yesterday. It was really pathetic. I just wish I could find someone ...
  • Hypocrisy Watch!
    Nothing says "conserve natural resources" like riding a toxic-gas-spewing rocket into space! The carbon footprint of a single lau...
  • Reinventing College
    TAE holds that the increasing cost of tuition is not increasing the quality of college education. Graduates are not smarter than they were,...
  • Here, I am. Send me.
    So I said: “Woe is me, for I am undone! Because I am a man of unclean lips, And I dwell in the midst of a people of unclea...
  • Haiti
    A youth minister in Haiti helping doctors writes to a friend of mine: I accompanied a small team of doctors to a hospital in Les Cayes that ...
  • TMQ has been reading TAE
    Gregg Easterbrook writes from ESPN : Soon, Barack Obama must make a decision on whether to continue funding NASA's daffy plan to build a...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2010 (147)
    • ►  June (10)
    • ►  May (18)
    • ►  April (37)
    • ►  March (21)
    • ►  February (31)
    • ►  January (30)
  • ▼  2009 (353)
    • ►  December (36)
    • ►  November (46)
    • ▼  October (45)
      • Why People Like Halloween
      • Thanks, readers!
      • One Out of Three Ain't Bad!
      • Adventures in Crackpot Relativistic Electrodynamics
      • Wikipedia
      • GOOD, 'CUZ THEY DESERVE IT!_
      • Obama visits Delaware
      • I, for one, welcome our Robot Overlords
      • The NASA report, Part 1: Problems
      • Deep Thought on Lala
      • Wonderful News
      • Saturday Poetry Burst
      • Generation Y Fundamentally Hated George W. Bush?
      • Get Excited! Or mad...
      • TAE to Mizzou: No More Night Games
      • Experts agree with TAE!!
      • Discrediting Liberalism, one "yes" at a time
      • Deep Thought
      • Polymaths
      • Deep Thought
      • TMQ has been reading TAE
      • Deep Thought on Economics
      • Deep Thought
      • Biomechanics are the Future of Sports
      • Third Option
      • Space Privatization, or How the Up Was Won
      • doomsday scenarios I'm fond of
      • Geothermal Heat Generation, the third option
      • Solar vs. Fusion
      • Sporadic Blogging This Past Week
      • Quote of the Day
      • Obama = Nobel Peace Prize. TAE = National Medal of...
      • Things that make Jim Carrey mad
      • Because, you know, we have no control over ourselves
      • Image of the Day
      • Outside the Beltway Caption Contest
      • Irony of the Week
      • Forward Progress
      • Think Tank...more like Genius Bank!!
      • I rest my case.
      • Rio de Janeiro gets 2016 Olympics
      • Department of Misleading Grammar
      • In Defense of NASA
      • Gretchen, stop trying to make "fetch" happen, ctd.
      • Cars that Drive Themselves, Ctd
    • ►  September (40)
    • ►  August (44)
    • ►  July (32)
    • ►  June (32)
    • ►  May (50)
    • ►  April (28)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

hony
View my complete profile